Blogs, News and Podcasts

View All View Blogs View News View Podcasts
  • Janice Caplan | 25th June 2018

    Too much feedback IS a bad thing.

     

    People benefit from feedback about their performance, and support for development. This is not in doubt. What is questionable however is how much feedback and support is beneficial.

     

    In two blogs, in December and January, I wrote against the trend for organizations to abandon annual performance reviews, and replace them with frequent, ‘check-in’ conversations between managers and their people. I expressed doubt about how worthwhile such conversations are. Surely, there comes a point when these conversations feel like someone breathing down your neck. Additionally, this idea of constant feedback runs counter to the notion of giving people more control over their work, and their time. Moreover, as I have also frequently written, managers today are far too over-stretched to be able to give the time required to such conversations. 

     

    Research published recently by Gartner1 and reported in the May/June Harvard Business Review supports my views. Gartner found that HR leaders expect managers to spend 36% of their time developing subordinates, whilst in reality managers spend just 9% on this. What Gartner also found, however, is that more coaching isn't necessarily better. The more effective managers - whom Gartner typify as 'Connector Managers' give targeted feedback in their areas of expertise; otherwise they connect people with those who are better suited to the task. The researchers say that managers should focus less on the frequency of their developmental conversations with employees and more on depth and quality. A viewpoint that matches ours entirely. 

     

     

    Click here to sign up to our online toolkit on developing new approaches to Talent and Performance Management in your organization. Or, Email us to sign up

    Click here to view our Privacy Policy.

     

    https://hbr.org/2018/05/managers-cant-be-great-coaches-all-by-themselves May–June 2018 issue (pp.22–24) of Harvard Business Review. About the Research: “Coaching vs. Connecting: What the Best Managers Do to Develop Their Employees Today,” by Gartner (white paper)

     

     

    Janice Caplan

    27 June 2018   

    ©Copyright Janice Caplan 2018

Ask a Question

close

 

Option 1:

Quick Question

First Name:

Surname:

Email Address:

Organisation:



Send

Option 2:

Add item to a Contact List

Add as many products or strategies as you want to a contact list.
When you are finished click the ‘Contact items’ button top or right.
You can then add a question and send to us.

 

This way we can easily see which items you are most interested in
in one email.

 

 

Add A Question:

First Name:

Surname:

Email Address:

Organisation:



Send

close

Shopping Basket

Your shopping basket is empty

Login or Register

Login

Email Address

Password

Login

Forgotten Password?

 

processing

 

Register

First Name:*

Surname:*

Company:

Position:

Phone:

Email:*

Password:*


*Mandatory fields. Password quick future access to downloads.



Send

 

processing

 

Login

Email Address

Password

Login

Forgotten Password?

Register

 

 

processing

Recover Password

Enter your email address and click 'Recover' to change your password.

Recover

Back to login

 

 

processing

Reset Password

Please enter your email address, new password and click 'Reset'

Email Address

New password

Confirm

Reset

Back to login

 

 

processing

Register

Already registered? Log In

 

First Name:*

Surname:*

Company:

Position:

Address1:

Address2:

Town:

County:

Postcode:

Phone:

Email:*

Password:*


*Mandatory fields. Password quick future access to downloads.



Send

 

processing

 

ACCEPT

Cookies

By clicking "Accept" you agree to the use of cookies to enhance your browsing experience. These cookies will anonymously analyse and measure engagement with our website content. Learn more about your choices and cookies. You can withdraw your consent at any time.