Blogs, News and Podcasts

View All View Blogs View News View Podcasts
  • Janice Caplan | 4th July 2018

    How much feedback and support is a good thing?

     

    Following on from last week’s blog about research conducted by Gartner1 that found that the quality of a feedback conversation is more important than frequency, I want to address this issue of quality. What makes a conversation developmental for the employee?

     

    Principally, this depends on the needs and expectations of the people being managed.

     

    These for sure will vary according to circumstances. For example, an employee who is more experienced in an activity will need less support, and also feedback about it. However, that same person will benefit from support and feedback in connection with a new responsibility where they have less experience. How effective the manager is in carrying out such 'coaching' conversations will also depend on key factors, such as how many direct reports they have, as this impacts significantly on their available time for such conversations, and how familiar they are with the area of expertise in question.

     

    From our work with clients, we have identified the following:

     

    The individuals themselves are the best qualified to identify the level of support and feedback they require and from whom. Responsibility for organising their own check-in conversations should be given firmly to them. Effectively the key coaching conversations that benefit individuals - to develop skills in a particular field, or plan their careers, or understand if their performance meets the required standard - might occur with several individuals rather than with a single manager. 

     

    The less formality there is around these conversations the better. For example, in one financial services firm, the legal counsel for the firm insisted that 'check-in' conversations had to be documented. Clearly, she had in mind the need to collect evidence in case of a dispute, over bonus or poor performance. This action turned a process that had been viewed as one of relationship-building, and enhancing collaboration to a bureaucratic exercise. It also made it more time-consuming and so it fell out of favour. It is far better to measure outcomes (e.g. employee satisfaction), and give public recognition to the process than it is to administer it, or even worse, police it.

     

    Click here to view our Privacy Policy.

    Click here to sign up to our online toolkit on developing new approaches to Talent and Peprformance Management in your organization. Or, Email us to sign up

     

    Janice Caplan

    4 July 2018   

    ©Copyright Janice Caplan 2018

    1 1 https://hbr.org/2018/05/managers-cant-be-great-coaches-all-by-themselves May–June 2018 issue (pp.22–24) of Harvard Business Review. About the Research: “Coaching vs. Connecting: What the Best Managers Do to Develop Their Employees Today,” by Gartner (white paper)

Downloads

How much feedback and support is good

Ask a Question

close

 

Option 1:

Quick Question

First Name:

Surname:

Email Address:

Organisation:



Send

Option 2:

Add item to a Contact List

Add as many products or strategies as you want to a contact list.
When you are finished click the ‘Contact items’ button top or right.
You can then add a question and send to us.

 

This way we can easily see which items you are most interested in
in one email.

 

 

Add A Question:

First Name:

Surname:

Email Address:

Organisation:



Send

close

Shopping Basket

Your shopping basket is empty

Login or Register

Login

Email Address

Password

Login

Forgotten Password?

 

processing

 

Register

First Name:*

Surname:*

Company:

Position:

Phone:

Email:*

Password:*


*Mandatory fields. Password quick future access to downloads.



Send

 

processing

 

Login

Email Address

Password

Login

Forgotten Password?

Register

 

 

processing

Recover Password

Enter your email address and click 'Recover' to change your password.

Recover

Back to login

 

 

processing

Reset Password

Please enter your email address, new password and click 'Reset'

Email Address

New password

Confirm

Reset

Back to login

 

 

processing

Register

Already registered? Log In

 

First Name:*

Surname:*

Company:

Position:

Address1:

Address2:

Town:

County:

Postcode:

Phone:

Email:*

Password:*


*Mandatory fields. Password quick future access to downloads.



Send

 

processing

 

ACCEPT

Cookies

By clicking "Accept" you agree to the use of cookies to enhance your browsing experience. These cookies will anonymously analyse and measure engagement with our website content. Learn more about your choices and cookies. You can withdraw your consent at any time.